One of five previous Barclays (BARC.L) investors on trial for the affirmed gear of a key Libor benchmark told a court on Friday he had lied about submitting rates for dealers since he felt under weight from his supervisor and the bank to "toe the line".
Jonathan Mathew told the court that he had felt compelled by his chief at the time, Peter Johnson, who members of the jury heard for the current week had confessed in October http://viewarffile.page.tl/ 2014 to contriving to control Libor.
Johnson is the primary man in Britain to concede to charges identified with Libor.
On Friday, Mathew told a London court that he had misled agents about taking solicitations from brokers in making entries to the benchmark, since he was concerned he would lose his occupation and was found about conflicting with his supervisor.
"He needed me to lie about us tolerating these solicitations", said Mathew of a discussion with his director. "I felt under weight."
Barclays declined to remark on Mathew's comments.
Mathew said he likewise felt weight from his manager, who had given him a composed cautioning about his behavior.
"The bank needed me to toe the line, I got the impression," he said. "Else they may need to pay a greater fine ... I was hitched to the falsehood."
Mathew said he changed his position after irregularities rose in meetings with the bank's legal counselors.
"More messages from swaps merchants were being discovered ... you were contending that dark is white," he told members of the jury.
He said that the United States Department of Justice drew nearer with a non-arraignment assention in 2011.
"They were stating they trust I was lying," he said. "They were correct. I was lying."
England's Serious Fraud Office affirms that Mathew and four of his previous partners - Jay Merchant, Ryan Reich, Alex Pabon and Stylianos Contogoulas - were deceptive when they submitted or requested that associates submit Libor rates, intended to be an autonomous appraisal of a bank's getting expenses, to advantage exchanging positions.
The five have argued not blameworthy to one charge of trick to dupe by controlling US dollar Libor rates somewhere around 2005 and 2007. Every tally conveys a most extreme prison sentence of 10 years.
The London Interbank Offered Rate is a benchmark utilized as a premise for estimating budgetary items from home advances to Visas worth many trillions of dollars all inclusive. Libor rates depend on the entries by banks.
Mathew, who is mostly hard of hearing, had said in his opening guard that he didn't do anything despicable or deceptive and was just doing what his manager let him know and taught him to do.
Mathew, now matured 35, was not responsible for entries and just made dollar Libor asks for when his supervisor was away, his legal counselor William Clegg had said in opening his safeguard.
Clegg prior on Friday read out to legal hearers messages amongst Contogoulas and Mathew in which Contogoulas said he will bring him espressos takeaway boxes from the Itsu sushi chain, in the wake of asking for certain Libor entries.
The U.S. dollar rose to an over two-week high against a wicker container of monetary forms on Friday taking after solid U.S. financial information, putting weight on oil costs, which fell following three days of increases.
Divider Street shut lower, with the Dow down 1 percent, as oil's decay delayed vitality offers. [.N]
U.S. retail deals in April recorded their greatest increment in a year as Americans ventured up buys of vehicles and different merchandise, proposing the economy was recovering energy.
Be that as it may, countering that confidence were lukewarm quarterly results from retail establishment administrators Nordstrom and J.C. Penney, taking after frail reports from different retailers prior in the week.
The S&P buyer optional segment fell 1.1 percent and purchaser staples offers dropped 1.2 percent.
"Absolutely this week there were sufficient information focuses that created some worry with financial specialists in regards to the strength of the buyer and, hence, the wellbeing of the general economy," said Chuck Carlson, CEO at Horizon Investment Services in Hammond, Indiana.
The Dow Jones modern normal fell 185.18 focuses, or 1.05 percent, to 17,535.32, the S&P 500 lost 17.5 focuses, or 0.85 percent, to 2,046.61 and the Nasdaq Compositehttp://viewarffile.jimdo.com/ dropped 19.66 focuses, or 0.41 percent, to 4,717.68.
The S&P and Dow inked their third straight weeks in the red, while the Nasdaq recorded a fourth straight negative week.
"We have had a week of blended information, progressing worry about local and worldwide development, and there simply hasn't been an explanation behind purchasers to come in," said Bucky Hellwig, senior VP at BB&T Wealth Management in Birmingham, Alabama.
The skillet European FTSEurofirst 300 file increased 0.6 percent, bouncing back from misfortunes prior in the session after the U.S. retail deals report.
Germany's economy dramatically increased its development rate in the principal quarter as spending got.
MSCI's wide file of worldwide shares dropped 0.9 percent.
The worldwide list, which fell for a third straight week, is off more than 1 percent for 2016. Worries about the worldwide economy continue and financial specialists are reacting to veering strategies between the Federal Reserve and other significant national banks.
Alongside the positive retail deals report, the University of Michigan said its shopper notion file surged 6.8 focuses to 95.8 early this month, the most noteworthy perusing since last June.
Taking after the peppy monetary information, the dollar was up 0.5 percent against a wicker bin of coinage.
The retail deals report "is prone to revive contentions from the hawkish camp in the progressing wrangle among strategy creators concerning why the Federal Reserve ought to consider keeping up its rate standardization endeavors," said Samarjit Shankar, head of iFlow and quant methodologies at BNY Mellon in Boston.
A three-day keep running up at oil costs stopped, hurt by the more grounded dollar and financial specialists capitalizing on late picks up. A more grounded U.S. coin weighs on greenback-designated products, for example, oil prospects.
Misfortunes were padded, nonetheless, by oil creation blackouts in Nigeria that have sliced yield there to the most reduced in over two decades.
Brent rough prospects settled down 0.5 percent at $47.83 a barrel. U.S. unrefined settled 1 percent lower at $46.21, in the wake of touching a six-month high on Thursday.
Oil costs have recouped some ground in the wake of touching 12-year lows prior in 2016.
In the U.S. government obligation showcase, the yield bend straightened the most in two months after the information. Short-and middle of the road dated obligation failed to meet expectations since quite a while ago dated bonds after the information.
Benchmark 10-year notes were last up 17/32 in cost to yield 1.7001 percent, down from 1.76 percent late on Thursday.
OPEC said the worldwide oil business sector is oversupplied and flagged the overabundance may build this year, as surging yield from its individuals compensates for misfortunes from different nations whose creation has been hit by a value fall.
Supply from the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) is moving after approvals on Iran were lifted and an activity with Russia and other non-individuals to handle a supply overabundance by solidifying yield fizzled a month ago.
OPEC pumped 32.44 million barrels for each day (bpd) in April, the gathering said in a month to month report refering to auxiliary sources, up 188,000 bpd from March. This is the most astounding following no less than 2008, as per a Reuters audit of past OPEC reports.
"Generally, oversupply still perseveres," OPEC said in the report distributed on Friday. "Oil yield stays high."
An industrious surplus could weigh on costs, which in spite of a recuperation to $47 a barrel from a 12-year low of $27.10 in January, are not as much as a large portion of their level in mid-2014. OPEC's 2014 procedure movement to shield piece of the pie against higher-cost rival yield developed the decrease.
The value drop is hitting non-OPEC supply as organizations have deferred or crossed out ventures the world over. OPEC estimates supply from outside makers will decrease by 740,000 bpd in 2016 drove by the United States, minimal changed from a month ago.
OPEC refered to elements that could prompt a greater supply drop, for example, the effect of out of control fires in Canada that have cut creation. The confirmation of falling non-OPEC supply ought to prompt a more grounded business sector one year from now, it said.
"Outside the U.S., there have been predictable indications of decreases in non-OPEC creation, which ought to likely flip the worldwide oil market into a net deficiency in 2017."
Yet, OPEC supply has been moving subsequent to the 2014 strategy shift drove by main two makers Saudi Arabia and Iraq. The arrival in December 2015 of Indonesia as an OPEC part has additionally expanded aggregate yield.
So far this year, Iran is driving the development. Tehran had declined to join the supply solidify activity and the arrangement went into disrepair on April 17 in Doha after Saudi Arabia demanded Iran participated.
OPEC left its figure that world oil http://viewarffile.bravesites.com/ interest will ascend by 1.20 million bpd this year unaltered. It sees interest for OPEC unrefined averaging 31.49 million bpd in 2016, extensively unaltered from a month ago's estimate.
The report focuses to a 950,000-bpd surplus by and large in 2016 if OPEC continues pumping at April's rate, up from 790,000 bpd inferred in a month ago's report.
The soundness of the world economy is relied upon to be a noteworthy center at the up and coming meeting of Group of Seven money pastors, given the expanding number of dangers to development, a senior Canadian authority said on Friday.
The subject of universal duty avoidance and shirking is additionally prone to be unmistakable in the wake of the supposed "Panama Papers", the Finance Department official told correspondents.
Policymakers will start the G7 meeting in Sendai, Japan one week from now with an examination of the key dangers to the worldwide monetary viewpoint and what strategy blend is the right one to support development.
While a few, including the International Monetary Fund, have called for nations to make more financial move as opposed to depending on national bank strategy to fortify development, a few nations have contended they don't have the space to take such measures.
Canada's new Liberal government uncovered a jolt spending plan recently that included framework spending to support development and Finance Minister Bill Morneau is relied upon to tout a development motivation and urge his G7 associates to concentrate on venture, the authority said.
Canada could discover a partner on this in the United States, however different nations at the table will likewise likely be thoughtful, the authority said.
The likelihood that Britain could vote in a choice one month from now to leave the European Union will likewise likely be examined. A vote to leave would have huge ramifications for Britain, the EU and the world economy however it is hard to know precisely what the effect would be early, the authority said.
With respect to developments in the remote trade showcases, the authority said he didn't anticipate that that will command the exchange as G7 individuals have been clear about the significance of not controlling coinage.
U.S. Treasury Secretary Jack Lew said before on Friday it was vital for G7 economies to strengthen vows to avoid aggressive money downgrades at their meeting one week from now.
Organization's net benefit tumbled to 961.2 million rupees ($14.39 million) on a standalone premise for the monetary final quarter finishing March 31, from 4.44 billion rupees a year prior, the Mumbai-based bank said in an administrative documenting on Friday.
Experts by and large had expected a net benefit of 2.43 billion rupees, as indicated by information assembled by Thomson Reuters.
Net terrible credits as a rate of aggregate advances expanded to 8.70 percent in the March quarter from 7.05 percent in the December quarter.
Japan's three driving automakers expect a more grounded yen will cost them around $14 billion in lost working benefit this year alone - pretty much as they have to put more in everything from cleaner fuel to driver-less autos.
Following three years of supernormal benefits on the back of a weaker coin, Toyota Motor, Nissan Motor and Honda Motor now confront a rude awakening as the yen has pivoted.
While the late years' coin aid has filled automakers' coffers - Toyota alone has around $10 billion in real money - a crush on edges will put them under weight to center their ventures, experts say.
"Step by step instructions to react to yen rises while securing benefits and proceeding with future ventures: this parity is vital," Toyota Executive Vice President Takahiko Ijichi said for this present week.
The U.S. dollar climbed approximately 60 percent against the yen between late-2011 and mid-2015, an immense godsend for Japan's auto creators, yet so far this year it is down about 9 percent against the Japanese coin.
Toyota, the world's biggest automaker, has figure a 40 percent drop in working benefits this year in view of the more grounded yen - a 935 billion yen ($8.6 billion) hit for an organization that sent out about a large portion of its Japanese generation a year ago. Honda estimate a 303 billion yen hit to its working benefit, while Nissan expects a "gigantic effect" of 255 billion yen on its working benefit.
Indeed, even automakers that have put more in nearby creation outside Japan expect some coin torment. Suzuki Motor Corp, which through its Maruti Suzuki wander has right around 50 percent piece of the overall industry in India, anticipates that yearly net benefit will fall by a fifth.
This is all cash that could be put resources into cleaner elective impetus frameworks, innovation to connection autos to information administrations and the improvement of self-sufficient driving.
In the United States, for instance, General Motors has put $500 million in ride-sharing administration Lyft to build up an on-interest system of independent vehicles. It likewise purchased Cruise Automation, a San Francisco start-up concentrated on creating driver-less autos.
Toyota has said it would set up an innovative work organization to concentrate on manmade brainpower in Silicon Valley, in a takeoff from its careful position on mechanized driving.
WINNOWING COSTS
Japan's 'huge three' automakers are, in any case, skirting on the preservationist with their expected yen rate of 105 to the dollar, which is more downbeat than a Reuters survey of outside trade investigators, which gauge the yen facilitating to 115 for every dollar by next April.
What's more, that is as of now having an effect.
Toyota figure its littlest ascent - a little more than 2 percent - in R&D putting in four years, to 1.1 trillion yen in 2017.
"We're seeing a one-two punch of yen quality consolidated with Japan Inc's propensity to give extremely preservationist direction," said Stefan Worrall, executive of Japan value deals at Credit Suisse.
"So you need to recognize some vulnerability over how much capex will really be affected by the more grounded yen since we're uncertain exactly the amount of misrepresentation we're seeing in faint income conjectures."
Nissan, whose advancement limits might be supported by a proposed tie-up with Mitsubishi Motors, has inclined up generation of its Rogue hybrid SUV in Japan, a model that has been offering admirably in the United States. That seemed well and good when the yen was powerless, less so now.
In any case, limit requirements mean Nissan has little any desire for changing its arrangements to expand Japan creation.
"We're not utilizing it as a methodology, we're utilizing it as an open door. We have limit accessible in Japan and no limit accessible in North America," said CEO Carlos Ghosn.
He called the more grounded yen a "monstrous headwind".
In the short term, organizations will http://viewarffile.jigsy.com/ hope to control costs, experts say - and that could be terrible news for Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's endeavors to animate a slowed down financial recuperation, as pay rates will probably be a prime target.
Account pastors from the world's biggest created economies met in Germany a year prior against a setting of floundering worldwide development, insufficient inflationary weights and the most recent part in the Greek obligation emergency.
When they and their G7 national bank associates assemble again in Japan next Friday the initial two things stay pretty much as risky and conceivably significantly trickier than a year prior. Just strangely smooth talks amongst Athens and its loan specialists may keep Greece off the plan this time around.
The hosts' money related and monetary strategy direction seems self-evident: the Bank of Japan is going under expanding weight to counter a harming ascend in the estimation of the yen that could wreck a delicate recuperation for the world's third-biggest economy.
Discuss more activity assembled pace after a scholarly seen to be near Governor Haruhiko Kuroda said the BOJ is liable to extend money related jolt either in June or July. The legislature has likewise said Tokyo is prepared to intercede in coin markets.
Whether expressly on the motivation or not, such intercessions are sure to be raised by partners from France, Italy, Germany, Britain, Canada and the United States either side of an arranged field trek to perceive how the northeastern Japanese city of Sendai has recuperated from the overwhelming 2011 seismic tremor.
In the first place quarter monetary development information on Wednesday ought to likewise add to the scenery with quarterly total national output (GDP) estimate to have extended by only 0.1 percent, as per a Reuters survey.
"The Bank of Japan has been vigorously censured for its choice not to take further monetary jolt measures at its meeting in April," said Commerzbank financial specialist Bernd Weidensteiner.
"Due to its refusal to bow to the business sector desires of 'to an ever increasing extent', the national bank at present faces an intense assignment to persuade the business sectors of its approach activities."
Bolstered PUZZLE
Things are not all that clear for the U.S. Central bank, which is gotten stuck a tough situation over when to push loan costs higher in the midst of worries about the soundness of the work market at home and fears about the thump on impacts its activities will have abroad.
There was crisp wavering among financial specialists in front of the discharge one week from now of the minutes from the April 26/27 Fed meeting when the national bank's rate-setting advisory group recognized that monetary development appeared to have moderated.
The Fed will probably hold up until September before raising rates once more, a Reuters survey discovered for the current week, extending to nine months the time since its first trek in almost 10 years as it sits tight for clear signs swelling is getting.
April's U.S. expansion figures touch base on Tuesday, a day prior to the euro zone give a report on its fight to enroll any sort of value development and that day Britain discharges its shopper value information for a month ago.
English value development is relied upon to have hindered after a get in March while jobless numbers on Wednesday may likewise demonstrate a plunge in enlisting in the main quarter as bosses turn wary in front of June's Brexit vote. Retail deals are expected on Thursday.
Most recent surveying on the EU participation submission will be pretty much as nearly watched to check whether the Bank of England's notice that a Brexit would moderate the economy pointedly, and could even push it into retreat, has had any effect on voters.
"Indications of a moderating economy and instability around Britain's EU submission seem to have brought about a movement in accentuation from lasting to makeshift contracting among UK bosses," Markit business analyst Oliver Kolodseike said. "The work business sector may there
Dependence Industries, proprietor of the world's greatest refining complex, delivered in 12 percent less oil in April contrasted and the earlier month in front of arranged upkeep shutdown of a few units at its 580,000-barrel-per-day (bpd) plant in western India, as per information acquired from exchange sources and ship-following administrations on the Thomson Reuters terminal.
Dependence, which has a broadened rough slate and moves buys to expand income, purchased around 1.19 million bpd a month ago, barely higher than a year prior.
Dependence, which had gotten Iranian oil in March following a hole of six years, did not get shipments from Tehran in April.
The offer of Latin American and African oil in Reliance's general imports declined in the initial four months of 2016, as the organization has moved sourcing from dated Brent-connected markets to the Middle East.
The offer of Middle Eastern rough in Reliance's general imports rose to around 57 percent in January-April from around 47 percent a year back, the information appeared.
Amid the same period, African evaluations represented around 6 percent of the unrefined acquired, contrasted and around 10 percent a year prior, while Latin American oil's offer shrank to around a third from 43 percent.Reliance's two propelled refineries in the condition of Gujarat in western India can together process 1.2 million bpd of oil, or around 26 percent of India's general limit.
India's center expansion remains somewhat higher than policymakers might want, yet the economy's recuperation ought to quicken with a decent storm, Reserve Bank of India (RBI) Governor Raghuram Rajan said on Friday.
The comments come a day after information indicated customer costs climbed a month ago at a more-than-anticipated 5.39 percent yearly rate, up from 4.83 percent in March. It was the principal increment in the retail expansion rate since January.
With Rajan focusing on 5 percent retail swelling by March 2017, his remarks will set the perspective that the RBI will hold loan fees enduring at its June 7 arrangement meeting. The bank slice rates a month ago to a four-year low of 6.5 percent in April.
"Extensively, center swelling has been genuinely sticky, somewhat higher than we would need. It hasn't climbed and down. We will proceed on the undertaking of mooring desires," Rajan said at an occasion at the Chicago Booth business college in London.
Center expansion strips out unpredictable things, for example, nourishment and vitality.
Rajan said development additionally appeared to tick higher. India's economy is among the world's quickest developing, at 7 percent-additionally, yet the 8 percent level expected to lighten neediness stays slippery. The most recent quarterly development was additionally slower than the earlier quarter.
"I think we are toward the starting or possibly amidst a moderate recuperation. The indications of quicker development are there - car deals for instance, concrete generation and utilization. What's more, a great solid storm would quicken the procedure of recuperation."
One issue for India is that banks stay hesitant to loan and to decrease rates for borrowers, in spite of 150 bps premise purposes of rate cuts in the previous year. To guarantee rate cuts sustain into the economy, the RBI has infused billions of rupees through open-market security buys and cut day by day upkeep of bank money hold proportions.
Rajan has made a need to of tidying up India's banks, which are loaded with focused on resources and have needed to make additional procurements for awful advances. He said the banks now had the instruments to manage the awful obligations.
"Presently they have instruments they can begin managing it ... parliament has quite recently passed the liquidation law, so I am cheerful the tidy up will happen and make the essential room banks need to loan," he said.
OPEC indicated a bigger oil supply surplus available this year as lifting of authorizations on Iran helps its yield, compensating for blackouts inside the gathering and misfortunes in outside makers hurt by the breakdown in costs.
The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries pumped 32.44 million barrels for each day (bpd) in April, the exporter bunch said in a month to month report on Friday refering to auxiliary sources, up 188,000 bpd from March.
OPEC and non-part makers including Russiahttp://www.viewarffile.sitew.in/#View_Arf.C fizzled at an April 17 meeting to consent to stop yield in an offer to handle a supply overabundance that has weighed on costs.
The April yield figure is OPEC's most noteworthy since no less than 2008, as per a Reuters survey of past OPEC gives an account of its site.
OPEC's report focuses to a 950,000-bpd overabundance supply by and large in 2016 if the gathering continues pumping at April's rate, up from 790,000 bpd suggested in a month ago's report.
Indian shares fell more than 1 percent on Friday after more grounded than-anticipated buyer expansion information raised the prospect the Reserve Bank of India would keep financing costs on hold, sending loan specialists, for example, State Bank of India pointedly lower.
The more extensive NSE Nifty shut 1.08 percent lower at 7,814.90, while the benchmark BSE Sensex finished down 1.17 percent at 25,489.57.
Be that as it may, both files posted their first week by week pick up in three, on income results which have so far demonstrated strong. Both lists picked up 1 percent for the week.
The International Sugar Organization (ISO) estimate on Friday a 2016/17 worldwide sugar shortfall of around 3.8 million tons on rising utilization and diminished yield prospects in number 2 maker India.
The London-based ISO, in its most recent quarterly report, raised its 2015/16 worldwide sugar deficiency gauge to 6.65 million tons, from its past figure made in February for a shortage of 5.0 million tons.
The Securities and Exchange Board of India has endorsed the arrangement of Ashok Chawla, the previous leader of the Competition Commission of India, as the new administrator of the National Stock Exchange (NSE), a representative at the bourse said on Friday.
Reuters reported a month ago that NSE, India's greatest trade, had named Chawla as its new executive after past holder S.B. Mathur ventured downward on finishing his residency.
China said it has consented to a multilateral arrangement to share charge data on multinational organizations, preparing for it to join the battle on worldwide duty shirking.
China marked the nation by-nation charge reporting assention, alongside Canada, India, Iceland, Israel and New Zealand, amid a meeting of the OECD Forum on Tax Administration (FTA) in Beijing this week, bringing the quantity of nations that have marked the settlement to 39.
Charge powers will "get a more finish comprehension of the way multinational undertakings structure their operations, while likewise guaranteeing that the privacy and the suitable utilization of such data is shielded", by proclamation issued on Friday, after the meeting.
The agreement was in accordance with the dedication made by G20 pioneers on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting, a project to battle worldwide expense evasion.
Created countries are attempting to get serious about expense provisos that permit multinational organizations to move benefits from high assessment nations to more casual purviews.
The dollar was set for a brief moment week of increases on Friday while securities exchanges fell in front of a modest bunch of major U.S. furthermore, Chinese information discharges which may do little to settle developing nerves over the viewpoint for the world's two greatest economies.
A poor execution on Wall Street on Thursday, driven by another huge drop in Apple offers, saturated Asian and European markets, down around a large portion of a percent in all cases. .FTSE .GDAXI .FCHI
Questions over development in Europe, the monetary strength of China and the U.S. Central bank's capacity to raise loan fees have overwhelmed the previous month and U.S. retail deals and Chinese discharges throughout the following 24 hours will be vital new bits of the photo.
The dollar - whose quality in the course of recent years is comprehensively an impression of how the United States is outpacing its companions - hit a two-week high against a wicker container of coinage on Friday, posting its best fortnightly execution since February.
"Hopefulness from prior this year that approach jolt in China would give more backing to monetary development in Asia has all the earmarks of being blurring," said Lee Hardman, a coin examiner with Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi in London.
"In these circumstances, item related and developing business sector monetary standards are returning under descending weight against the dollar."
Information toward the end of the Chinese exchanging day indicated banks amplified only 555.6 billion yuan ($85.22 billion) in net new yuan advances in April, well underneath investigators' desires and not as much as a large portion of the 1,370 billion yuan reported in March.
A solid perusing of first quarter development from Germany and a modest bunch of other euro zone economies did little to light up the state of mind.
While development in Germany multiplied, Berlin's economy service cautioned it would moderate in the second quarter and financial experts said weaker fares to abating developing markets like China would in the end start to tell on interest.
After a poorer arrangement of occupations numbers a week ago there are likewise more questions over how hearty the U.S. economy will go ahead.
Two Fed policymakers - Eric Rosengren and Esther George - both sounded idealistic on the odds of raising loan costs in the not so distant future in remarks late on Thursday. Be that as it may, U.S. financing cost markets hinted at small needing to trust them: evaluating demonstrates the odds of rates being unaffected before the current year's over have ascended to around 40 percent.
Still, both are voters on the U.S. national bank's strategy board of trustees this year and the remarks by Boston Fed President Rosengren, in the previous a supporter of keeping rates low for more, indicate the developing weight inside the bank for a trek this year.
Asian shares fell after the rough execution on Wall Street, MSCI's broadest list of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan .MIAPJ0000PUS down 1.1 percent, and on track for its third straight week after week decay.
No comments:
Post a Comment